What Role Do Surveillance Footage and Digital Evidence Play in Injury Cases?

In 1986, the NFL instituted instant replay to review calls on the field, years after sportscaster Warner Wolf made “Let’s go to the videotape!” his catchphrase. Since then, we’ve become accustomed to relying on the “replay” to confirm what really happened in all kinds of circumstances. Nowhere is that more relevant than in personal injury cases.

If there is a car accident or a slip-and-fall in a store, surveillance footage can help determine exactly what happened. Securing that footage might occasionally be a challenge. A store owner might not be forthcoming, especially if the footage shows they are liable. Tracking down traffic camera footage can also be complex because many of those cameras stream live images without saving them, and any recordings may be kept only briefly. That is why you need to retain an experienced Charleston premises liability attorney to help secure the footage.

How Surveillance Footage Helps Establish Liability

You might not always spot the surveillance cameras, but they’re out there. Several traffic cameras around Charleston, part of the state’s West Virginia 511 system, provide weather and traffic condition surveillance. When that footage is recorded, it can also capture critical details of an accident that eyewitnesses might overlook or remember incorrectly. Depending on the camera’s location and recording quality, video evidence may reveal the conditions leading to an accident, the incident itself, and what happened afterward.

Additionally, surveillance footage from a grocery store might show a customer slipping on a liquid spill. The footage could help establish how long the spill was on the floor and whether employees walked past it without attempting to clean it up or warn other customers.

Surveillance recordings can help establish several important issues in a premises liability claim:

  • Hazardous conditions: Footage from a store’s security cameras might document wet floors, damaged stairs, obstructed walkways, or inadequate lighting. Any of those factors could contribute to a slip-and-fall accident.
  • Actual or constructive notice: Recordings can show that a property owner knew about a dangerous condition. They can also show that the danger existed long enough that the owner reasonably should have discovered it.
  • The timeline: Video footage can establish what occurred immediately before, during, and after an injury.
  • Negligent security: If inadequate security contributed to your injury, cameras can document suspicious activity and the lack of a proper security response.
  • Comparative negligence: Under state law, West Virginia follows a modified comparative negligence rule, which bars recovery only if you were more at fault than everyone else combined. Surveillance footage can show whether you contributed to the accident or took reasonable precautions.

Surveillance footage does not automatically establish negligence. That evidence must be evaluated alongside the property owner’s legal duties and other circumstances surrounding the incident. An experienced attorney can provide the proper context for any footage that supports your claim.

Why Preserving Surveillance Footage Is Critical

One of the biggest challenges involving digital evidence is that it can disappear quickly. Many businesses use surveillance systems that automatically overwrite older recordings. Traffic camera systems that record at all may keep footage for an even shorter time. Depending on the system’s storage capacity, valuable footage could be erased within days or weeks.

After an accident, you should act promptly to identify potential sources of video evidence. Your attorney can send a formal preservation letter to the property owner or government agency requesting that relevant recordings and electronic records be retained.

A preservation request should identify the incident’s date, time, and location and seek footage from a reasonable period before and after the accident. If a party destroys relevant evidence despite a legal duty to preserve it, that destruction is considered “spoliation of evidence.”

In that scenario, a West Virginia judge can give the jury an adverse inference instruction. That means jurors may assume the missing footage would have been unfavorable to the party that destroyed it.

Common Types of Surveillance Footage Used to Prove Liability

Surveillance footage can provide critical evidence for your personal injury claim. Depending on where an accident occurs, several types of recordings can help establish liability.

Consider the following:

  • Business security cameras
  • Parking lot and garage cameras
  • Residential security cameras
  • Traffic and intersection cameras
  • Dashboard cameras
  • Workplace surveillance systems
  • Public transportation cameras

Video is not the only digital evidence. Phone records, vehicle data recorders, and electronic maintenance or inspection logs can fill in what the cameras missed.

Your personal injury attorney can help locate any potential recordings and request their preservation. Once the recordings are secured, your attorney can review them thoroughly to determine how the evidence supports your personal injury claim.

Protecting Your Right to Compensation with Strong Digital Evidence

Surveillance footage and digital evidence can make a significant difference in a personal injury claim. It can help establish how an accident occurred and identify any negligent parties. The goal is to act quickly to collect that evidence before it is lost. The attorneys at Hendrickson & Long, PLLC understand the importance of securing critical evidence. If we agree your case has merit, we can immediately send preservation letters to secure any relevant footage. That will be just one part of our complete investigation into your accident.

Our goal is to build a case strong enough to stand up to the insurance company’s challenges. Contact us today to schedule a consultation to discuss what happened. When the insurance company pushes back on your claim, and you have that footage, you can confidently claim, “Let’s go to the videotape!”